4.28916827853 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Rating 4.29 (517 Votes)
Episode 1.2: The Story Girl Earns Her Name - 3.5 out of 5 based on 4 votes

Sara befriends the reclusive inventor Jasper Dale and together they stage a magic lantern show to replace stolen school library funds.

Writer: Heather Conkie
Director: Bruce Pittman
Special Guest: RH Thomson as Jasper Dale 
With: John Gilbert as Mr. Campbell, Barbara Gordon as Mrs. Ray 
Original CBC Airdate: January 14, 1990 
Original Disney Airdate: March 12, 1990
Run Time: 46 minutes
Time Frame: June 1903

Highlights/Analysis

A travelling con man skips town with the school library funds. Sara befriends the reclusive inventor Jasper Dale and together they stage a magic lantern show to replace stolen school library funds.

Jasper Dale is harassed by Sara's rival Sally Potts and fellow lackey Jane Spry. The girls' taunting ends in disaster when Jasper fumbles the magic lantern projector, and consequently sets the hall ablaze. Sara and her cousins confront Sally and force her to confess her actions, afterward dropping her into the leech infested school pond.

There appears to be a theme with Fanny Tarnbush that gold digging and money grubbing don't pay; however, it's interesting to note that the thief, Mr. Beedy, escapes and there is no mention that he ever pays for his crime.

Criticism

At the magic lantern show, Sara renders a presentation of Hans Christian Andersen's "The Little Match Girl." It would have been more appropriate if Sara would have recited a story from the Lucy Maude Montgomery's novels "The Story Girl" or "The Golden Road." Wasn't the point of Montgomery's character to evoke the haunting tales of her ancestry? Presumably, the Andersen story was somewhat related to the subplot concerning wealthy entrepreneur Wellington Campbell's grief over the memories of his deceased mother

Memorable Quotes

"Well Sara Stanley, I have never been so humiliated in all my life!" -Felicity King.

"Next to Sally Potts, Felicity is a saint." -Felix King

"Sara the story girl, what a joke. Tells a tale and it goes up in smoke." -Sally Potts.

Notes

(1) This episode features the first appearances of Jasper Dale and Wellington Campbell. Both characters appear in The Story Girl when Sara and the King cousins are asking for donations to build a Carlisle school library. The children encounter Jasper Dale in "Chapter VI: The Mystery of Golden Milestone" and find the "awkward man" to be a gentleman. In the following chapter, "How Betty Sherman Won A Husband," the stingy miser Campbell agrees to contribute to the library fund if Sara can amuse him by telling the story of his Grandmother Betty Sherman. Campbell is satisfied with her story weaving abilities, donates 5 dollars to the fund and peculiarly asks Sara to recite the multipication tables. 

(2) In notes for the Road to Avonlea Original Soundtrack, composer John Welsman wrote that "For Sarah's theme, I wanted the music to suggest the kind of freedom of spirit and elegance that the young Sarah Stanley possessed -- her strength and determination as well as her softness. 'The Story Girl' theme was originally composed for scenes of her running freely through the fields near Avonlea in 'The Story Girl Earns Her Name', but after hearing it, Kevin Sullivan chose it for the 'Main Title' music for the series." The soundtrack was a special feature released with theRoad to Avonlea Complete Sixth Volume DVD set. 

(3) Throughout the rest of the series, Sara Stanley focuses less on her story weaving skills, and more on her desire to mend the the romantic affairs and lost loves of the Avonlea villagers.

(4) Although they appear in the series, Fanny Tarnbush and Edward Ray are not featured in the credits.

Grade: A- 

The inclusion of a Sara Stanley tale from "The Story Girl" in place of Andersen's story would have been a nice way to draw more closely from the Montgomery books.

Leave a comment

Post comment as a guest

0 / 5000 Character restriction
Your text should be less than 5000 characters

People in this conversation

  • Michael G.

    This is my favorite episode of season 1. It introduces us to Jasper Dale in a more relaxed setting with young Sara. We see, unfortunately, the only time the Story Girl is allowed to live up to her moniker. The magic lantern show is brilliantly filmed as it combines shots of Sara's haunting story with Jasper's operation of the camera. It makes me wonder, has anybody seen another magic lantern show on film or TV?

  • I don't believe I have seen another magic lantern show represented before on television or film. Interestingly, this website was originally called 'The Magic Lantern' or 'Avonlea Magic Lantern.' Shortly after it was launched, I received an email from a traveling magic lantern company that boasted 'America's only Authentic 1890's Magic Lantern Show.' They mainly wanted to exchange URL links.

    One of the important things that was lacking in 'The Story Girl' that the writers brought to the series was the use of stronger antagonists. I enjoyed the rivalry between Sally and Sara in these early seasons, particularly this episode where Sally and Jane disrupt Sara and Jasper's presentation; and how Sara retaliates by forcing Sally to walk the school pond plank. Otherwise, there is very little tension in the books outside of playful family rivalries.

  • Newbie

    Has anyone else noticed that Sara is holding her hands backwards during the show? Her shielding hand is under the hand holding the match. Unless that match is burning upside down.