The following list represents the fan rated Road to Avonlea episodes for season two, starting with the highest rated episode (#1) and ending with the least favorite episode (#13). You may start voting by going to 'Rate the Avonlea Episodes.'
| Rank | Episode | Avg. Score | Votes Counted |
| 1 | A Mother's Love | 4.77 | 380 |
| 2 | How Kissing Was Discovered | 4.76 | 508 |
| 3 | Aunt Hetty's Ordeal | 4.73 | 410 |
| 4 | Misfits and Miracles | 4.55 | 314 |
| 5 | May the Best Man Win | 4.36 | 297 |
| 6 | Old Quarrels, Old Love | 4.35 | 310 |
| 7 | All That Glitters | 4.32 | 305 |
| 8 | Sea Ghost | 4.27 | 307 |
| 9 | Dreamer of Dreams | 4.08 | 260 |
| 10 | Sara's Homecoming | 3.85 | 330 |
| 11 | Family Rivalry | 3.81 | 273 |
| 12 | Corsets Secrets and True Love | 3.73 | 317 |
| 13 | It's Just a Stage | 3.11 | 255 |